HOAleader.com provides practical advice on homeowner and condominium association management, laws, rules, insurance, finances, reserves, dues, liens, assessments, dispute resolution, and more.HOAleader.com provides practical advice on homeowner and condominium association management, laws, rules, insurance, finances, reserves, dues, liens, assessments, dispute resolution, and more.
HomeBrowse by TopicDiscussion ForumResearchSearchMember Log-in
Sign up for the FREE
Tip of the Week
Free Newsletter
Discussion Forum
Follow on Twitter
 RSS Feed
New Headlines
Most Popular
Special Reports
Vendor Directory
Join HOAleader.com
Members-Only Home
Group Discounts
Renew Membership
About HOAleader.com
HOA Vendors
Our Guarantee
Text Size
Contact Us
Your Privacy
Published by Plain-English Media, LLC
Home | Weekly E-Zine | HOA Board Beware: Are You Breaking A . . .

HOA Board Beware: Are You Breaking Antitrust Laws?

June 28, 2013
Printer-Friendly Format

In this week's tip, we discuss a South Carolina lawsuit, Brandriff v. Dataw Island Club Inc., in which association board members were sued by owners for, among other things, antitrust violations.

In Brandriff, the home owners contended the board had conspired to create policies that benefited golf club members at the expense of HOA members who didn't join the golf club; that the board raised assessments on HOA owners and then transferred some of those funds to benefit the golf club; that the HOA illegally yoked--in antitrust law, it's called "tying"--membership in the HOA to membership in the golf club; that the HOA restricted owners' right to purchase membership in other golf clubs; among other allegations.

All of those wrongs stemmed, according to the plaintiffs' allegations, from actions taken in 2001. Before then, membership in the golf club had been optional for HOA owners. However, that year, the board proposed and the owners eventually agreed to amend the bylaws to adopt the "One Island" concept. The plaintiffs alleged that it required all owners to become members of the golf club with the promise the change wouldn't lead to increased assessments for capital improvements at the golf club and that existing and grandfathered non-golf club members wouldn't be charged for any amenity assessments or club dues. The plaintiffs allege both of those promises were breached.

In 2010, the federal court dismissed the owners' lawsuit. The plaintiffs' response? They refiled their suit in state court, and the court's website reports the case as still pending.

It is unusual for an HOA board to be sued for antitrust violations. But it's not unheard of. "I haven't seen this actual case, but it's very, very similar to one we had locally several years ago," says Elizabeth White, a shareholder and head of the community associations practice at the law firm of LeClairRyan in Williamsburg, Va. "In that case, under the so-called tying arrangement, if you purchased a lot, you were automatically a member of a separate equity club. Members of the association balked at it, particularly when there was a special assessment at the club level to rebuild one of the golf holes.

Find out more about both cases, and what you can do to avoid landing in court yourself, in our new article: HOA Board Members Sued for Antitrust Violations: Will It Succeed?

Best regards,
Matt Humphrey

Printer-Friendly Format
·  HOA Board Members Sued for Antitrust Violations: Will It Succeed?

 Free White Papers

HOA Finances:
Best Practices for Getting Your Homeowners Association through Difficult Economic Times

Download now »

Advertising Information
Dispute Resolution
Facilities & Maintenance
Financial Matters
HOA Elections
HOA Governance
HOA Insurance
HOA Reserves
HOA Rules
Human Resources
Legal Compliance
Security & Safety
HOA Glossary
Complete Topic List

 Discussion Forum
Recent Forum Posts
· HOA responsibility for water hammer
· Public disclosure of delinquent fee condo owners
· Members-At-Large
· HOAleader.com on-demand webinars
· election of board
· Lawyer's fee
· HELP We are past our rejuvenation period
· Licensed Contractors And Workman's Compensation
· Counting Election Results
· Liability Umbrella Policy for HOA
· Parking Violation
· Who Pays For What In A Condominium?
· Common Area
· HO-6 Homeowner's Insurance
· HOA Board President
Search Discussion


Here's what our readers
are saying ...


"Your news and ideas have been a Godsend and so helpful, you can't imagine... Thanks for everything."

Saundra Ragona
Quail Ridge Owners' Association

"We really appreciate your publication. It's as if you had a spy at our meetings and over hear our gripes :). Keep up the good work."

Cynthia Ramnarace
Palmer's Landing HOA

"This is a great service."

Mark R. Benson
Past Chairman of the Florida Community Association Living Study Council
Past Member of the Regulatory Council of Community Association Managers
Past Vice-Chairman of the Advisory Council on Condominiums County Court Mediator

"I am a newly elect President of a small (10 units) HOA / Condo, and I am learning the business almost from scratch ... Thanks for your very valuable information."

Volodymyr (Vlad) Boryshpolov
1102 Avenue X HOA

"Thanks for all your great HOA tips! I am a new Board Secretary—your site is truly worth signing up for!"

Kathie Norris
Whispering Pines West HOA